Watch: Greens support 18,000 lowest income families

In the Wirral Council’s Policy and Resources Committee the Greens proposed to reconsider the cuts to Council Tax Reduction Scheme made earlier this year. These cuts have significantly increased the Council Tax bills for the lowest income homes.

[Resident Jess Ryan] Wirral Council has made the decision to triple the council tax for 18,000 of the most vulnerable people and families. By cutting the council tax support scheme, that caused an increase of £555 per household. For me personally, that increased my bill to £800 a year.

[Cllr Jo Bird] This has caused huge hardship. I'd like to move the officer recommendations to consult on changes to council tax reduction scheme, with the aim of reducing the burden on residents facing financial hardship.

[Resident Jess Ryan] Currently, I'm a one-income family. I'm also a full -time carer for my son, which is the most important aspect of my life. Increasing this bill has caused incredible distress. I genuinely worry for the health and well-being of those people like me, who are already in a challenging situation, which is only made worse by these cuts. I applied for the hardship relief fund that was specifically allocated to help those who would struggle with this increase. I was declined, as were most of the other people who applied. The decline rate is 63.6%. In my case, my son's daily payments were taken into consideration as part of my income.

[Jan from ‘Unite’ communty] A member who is a WASPy woman who has already been hit by the delay in receiving her pension is now finding she has an increased council tax bill. When she should be enjoying retirement, she is having to claim universal credit. Continue to look for work and manage her household finances on a far lower income than she had planned. The previous council tax support she received at least helped keep on top of her bills. Now she is having to make the decision whether to risk a court hearing from council tax, go hungry or freeze. A 20-year-old recently finished college who has no family support and is on lower universal credit payments due to his age. As under 25s are on £86 less a month than a person who is over 25.

[Cllr Amanda Onwuemene on behalf of residents Patty and Tom Allport] Many vulnerable adults are compelled to pay because of their condition. They have no choice in the matter. They will pay the council tax but they will not put the heating on, such is their mindset. They'll sit in the dark and the cold, runny-nosed, coughing and barking. But the council tax will be paid. This council have no idea of how vulnerable people live with the further anxiety and misery that this liability has had on them. Not to mention the fear of being evicted from their home if they don't pay their council tax. Because council has not carried out an economic impact study on this policy.

[Cllr Jo Bird] As we all know, council tax is collected under threat of court action and bailiffs. And even with that pressure, council officer reports show that only £4.18 million, that's 58%, of the increased council tax bills are forecast to be paid this year. So there are £3 million, that's 42% of the increased council tax that is not paid. If 42% of the eligible households are not paying their council tax on time, that's 7,200 households in council tax arrears due to this rise. Most of those households have children. Children with stressed parents who cannot pay the bills. Imagine you are a child in a family that in January had a council tax bill of £28 a month, but now they have to pay £84 a month for 10 months. What does that do to a child in your formative years and your healthy start in life? We talked earlier about the huge healthy life discrepancies on the Wirral. 25 years difference, the worst in the country. So what do other councils do? The research is online by 'Entitled To'. They show that Wirral's 50% council tax support is in the top three meanest councils in the whole country. Wirral is the cruelest out of 300 councils and that's really not where we should be. We're told that Wirral Council has really difficult financial circumstances, which it absolutely does. But we're also told that there is no alternative. But over 50 councils in this country also face similar pressures as Wirral on adults, on children's and housing services and cannot balance their budget without government bailout loans, the exceptional financial support. Some of those councils charge for car parking, some have three weekly bin collections, some don't. All of those councils have set a council tax scheme that is much more generous than Wirral's, apart from Enfield, which is the same as Wirral's at 50%. For many of the councils, it's exactly the opposite. Councils like Gloucester, Somerset, Trafford, Woking and Worthing, they all have exceptional financial support and they have kept 100% council tax support. They recognise the net effect of putting families into poverty and debt is not acceptable and puts even more pressure on council services. So there is an alternative. If other councils can keep their council tax support, then so can Wirral. We could reverse the council tax support back down to 17.5%. The extra £4.2 million in revenue could be included in the council's budget pressures, alongside the £66 million that the Director of Finance outlined before. It's just a 6% increase in the pressures. Senior officers could bring forward proposals to balance the budget as they do every year. And it's not rocket science. It is their job.

[Cllr Gail Jenkinson] I just want to make it clear that we did bring forward proposals to budget last year, but you have to get through the monitoring officer and the Section 151 officer. And they weren't prepared to let our proposals come to budget council. So...

[Councillors start heckling]

[Cllr Gail Jenkinson] No, they were legal. They were legal.

[heckler] So they were legal then? No, they weren't.

[Chair] Councilors, please.

[Cllr Gail Jenkinson] None of the proposals were illegal in terms of setting the budget. It's just that they...

[heckler] The numbers didn't add up.

[Cllr Gail Jenkinson] No, they did add up, but the 151 officer wouldn't let them through.

[Cllr Ed Lamb] There are precedents for consulting on this at this time of year. Solihull consulted from the 19th of November tomorrow, back last year, till 7th of January on changes to their scheme.

[Cllr Ruth Molyneux] This council tax reduction scheme has already deepened existing poverty. And we can see that when we look at figures for the hardship fund, which is already more than 54,000 in expense. And the 9,964 court summonses that have been issued. And that's more than the year total for each of the previous three years. New data published last month shows the widening inequalities across Wirral, with a 25-year gap for health outcomes between east and west of this borough. Just pause to think about that for a minute. Someone in central Birkenhead will develop a life-limiting illness 25 years before someone in the more affluent west of the borough. The largest gap in England. Now that's absolutely shocking. These aren't just numbers. They represent real people and real families who have very different life chances. And no sign of it improving any time soon. Because poverty and debt harms your physical and mental health through the daily material strain and chronic stress. And it creates a cycle where poor health can in turn worsen your financial hardship. And some people do ask if the people who voted for this cruel and spiteful scheme even stopped for a minute to consider the effects it would have on our most vulnerable families. Or did they just not care? But surely we all wanted to be here because we do care. So prove it. Prove it. We have a chance to do that here tonight by voting for this amendment. To just go to consultation. That's all we're asking.

[Cllr Jo Bird] We've heard that we can't revisit decisions already made. It's been said a few times. Does that mean regardless of new evidence? Regardless of the fact that this year 9,965* households have been summoned to court already. Way more than last year, the year before and the year before put together. So we can't revisit that decision because the new evidence doesn't count. And no matter how many children and families are put into more debt because of this really cruel decision. It was interesting to hear the Councillor for Heswall talk so stridently against increasing support for people on the lowest incomes when it's 115 households in Heswall that are affected by Council Tax Reduction Scheme. Whereas we heard earlier from Councillor Amanda Onwuemene, 2,308 households in Birkenhead and Tranmere are affected by this scheme. And it's no wonder that the healthy life expectancy between those two wards is 25 years. We can do something to change that. More business as usual is going to produce the same awful returns. And so I do urge you to agree to just consult with a view to bring in the scheme down to make it fairer for people. And yeah, I think I know how the vote's going to go. Everyone's made their position pretty clear.

[Chair] OK, and on that note, we will go move straight to the vote. So for the amendment proposed by the Green Party, can I have those in favour of that, please?

4 Green Cllrs Vote FOR consultation to improve Council Tax support

Those against?

8 Labour, 1 Reform, 4 Tory and 2 Lib Dem Cllrs vote AGAINST improving Council Tax support

The amendment is lost.

November 2026

Next
Next

Liverpool Together Unity March